Will We Get Joaquin’s Remnants?

vis_lalo-animated

 

As of 2100 GMT today Joaquin is still a Category 1 hurricane of 70 knots, racing east-northeastwards towards cooler waters below the 26 °C threshold. These cooler waters and increased shear should cause Joaquin to lose tropical characteristics during Wednesday and become an extratropical depression as it passes near to the Azores Friday and continues towards mainland Europe. The question is, where in Europe will it end up, if at all? The signals are still very mixed!

The latest official forecast from the National Hurricane Center (NHC) in Miami has the remnants of Joaquin as a 35-knot depression at 49N 10W (about 250 km due south of the southwest Kerry coast) by 1800 GMT on Sunday 11th. This is their best estimate, based on all available data at present. This would give some stiff southeasterly to easterly winds and bands of rain over Ireland, southwest England and northwest France.

204122

This is just one solution, put together by both man and machine working together. The problem with the “machine” is that different machines (computer models) are giving very different forecasts at the moment, so trying to decide which is right and which is wrong requires the input of the human. These guys have vast experience with these systems, and it at times like this that this experience is put into action.

But let’s take a look at the different models, starting with the one that has by far performed the best during Joaquin, the European ECMWF. Today’s midday run shows the remnants actually splitting in two and heading off in totally different directions, one to Iceland and the other to Spain! Ireland is sitting pretty there in the middle, with a ridge of high pressure bringing settled conditions. As I said, this model has been the best of late, and one that the NHC have favoured, however on this occasion they seem to be discounting it.

ECMWF 12Z run, showing Joaquin's remnants actually split into two; one branch over Iceland, the other over Spain. Image from www.vedur.is
ECMWF 12Z run, showing Joaquin’s remnants actually split into two by midnight Saturday; one branch over Iceland, the other over Spain. Image from http://www.vedur.is

The American model, the GFS, has a totally different solution, with a deep depression right over Ireland. This would bring strong southerly winds and heavy rain during Saturday night and Sunday, in vast contrast to the settled conditions hinted by the ECMWF. The ECMWF tends to be better because it ingests more observational data than the GFS, however the NHC forecast is more in line with the GFS in this case.

ex Joaquin GFS
12Z GFS model run, showing Joaquin’s remnant depression right over Ireland, bringing strong southerly winds and heavy rain. Image from http://www.ogimet.com

The UK Met Office FAX chart (produced by human forecasters) shows a 975 hPa low centred at 54N 18W, or about 300 km due west of Galway. Their own model (UKMO) shows nothing of the sort, with the depression heading through Biscay and northern Spain as it fills during Saturday night and Sunday. This would mean the Met Office are disregarding their own model and are going for something different to the other two as well.

12Z UKMO chart for Sunday, showing a flabby remnant low along northern Spain. Image from www.meteociel.fr
12Z UKMO chart for Sunday, showing a flabby remnant low along northern Spain. Image from http://www.meteociel.fr

The other models; the German ICON, Canadian GEM, Japanese JMA and US NAVGEM, all show a similar picture of the low ending up somewhere around northwest Iberia by Sunday, much like the UKMO and the southerly breakaway of the ECMWF. This would hint at some consistency and agreement between most of the models, however the forecasting agencies themselves see varyingly different outcomes, and these don’t tend to agree with one another!

What I’m trying to say is no-one really knows what exactly will become of ex Joaquin. It is pretty sure to bring some strong winds to the Azores on Friday, but after that opinions vary. What we do know is that no amount of speculation by me or anyone else is going to affect the many physical processes at play in the atmosphere that will ultimately determine where Joaquin will see out his days. They say a butterfly flapping its wings in Brazil can cause a rainstorm in New York, but fingers tapping on a laptop keyboard usually only generate a lot of hot air, especially when the laptop belongs to a tabloid journalist!

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Will We Get Joaquin’s Remnants?

  1. This is one historic storm – if only from the point of view that it has defied the computer models and human forecasters attempts to predict it’s actual path.

    This is not the fault of the forecasters or the computer models but an indication and reminder of how difficult it is to produce a weather forecast with the various complexities of the atmosphere even given all the human and computer resources available.

    Sometimes you just have to toss a coin.

    • Yes, but one thing has been reaffirmed out of all this; the ECMWF’s superiority yet again. Just like with Sandy it went out on a limb and was the only model predicting Joaquin to miss the US. The others all followed suit a few days later but the ECMWF had it nailed, and yet again we see it successfully predict it finishing up around Spain while the GFS had it right over us.

  2. Thank you for sharing excellent informations. Your website is very cool. I”m impressed by the details that you’ve on this website. It reveals how nicely you perceive this subject. Bookmarked this website page

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s